Ira R. Forman

23 papers A* 5A 5B 2Journal 1Unranked 9
YearRankTypeTitle / Venue / Authors
2012 A conf
ASSETS
Ira R. Forman, Ben Fletcher, John Hartley, Bill Rippon, Allen Wilson
2009 conf
HCI (7)
Ira R. Forman, Thomas Brunet, Paul Luther, Allen Wilson
1999 conf
Reflection and Software Engineering
Ira R. Forman
1998 conf
TOOLS (26)
Ira R. Forman
1996 book
Interacting processes - a multiparty approach to coordinated distributed processing.
Nissim Francez, Ira R. Forman
1995 A conf
OOPSLA
Ira R. Forman, Michael H. Conner, Scott Danforth, Larry K. Raper
1994 A conf
OOPSLA
Ira R. Forman, Scott Danforth, Hari Madduri
1994 conf
TOOLS (13)
Scott Danforth, Ira R. Forman
1994 A conf
OOPSLA
Scott Danforth, Ira R. Forman
1991 B conf
CONCUR
Nissim Francez, Ira R. Forman
1990 conf
ICCL
Nissim Francez, Ira R. Forman
1990 conf
Jerusalem Conference on Information Technology
Nissim Francez, Ira R. Forman
1990 conf
Programming Concepts and Methods
Shmuel Katz, Ira R. Forman, Michael Evangelist
1990 A conf
ICDCS
Paul C. Attie, Ira R. Forman, Eliezer Levy
1990 B conf
CONCUR
Nissim Francez, Ira R. Forman
1989 conf
IWSSD
Ira R. Forman
1988 A* conf
ICSE
Michael Evangelist, Vincent Y. Shen, Ira R. Forman, Mike Graf
1986 conf
FJCC
Ira R. Forman
1984 A* conf
ICSE
Ira R. Forman
1984 J jnl
Inf. Process. Manag.
Bill Curtis, Ira R. Forman, Ruven E. Brooks, Elliot Soloway, Kate Ehrlich
1984 A* conf
ICSE
Ted J. Biggerstaff, D. Mack Endres, Ira R. Forman
1982 A* conf
ICSE
Ira R. Forman
1981 A* conf
ICSE
Ira R. Forman
tests/unit/test_apk_process_method.py
← Index tests/unit/test_apk_process_method.py python
"""Mock-based tests for APKCodeAnalyzer._process_method and androguard integration.

Tests the boundary between our code and androguard objects, covering:
- xref extraction (get_xref_from / get_xref_to) for both 4.x and 3.x APIs
- external method skipping
- library method filtering
- smali lookup and androguard fallback disassembly
- deduplication of content hashes
- full output population (all result dict keys)
- minimum instruction filtering
"""
from dataclasses import dataclass
from typing import List
from unittest.mock import MagicMock, Mock, patch, PropertyMock

import pytest

pytestmark = [pytest.mark.unit, pytest.mark.apk, pytest.mark.decompile]


# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
# Helpers: build mock androguard objects
# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------

SAMPLE_SMALI_BODY = """\
.locals 2
const/4 v0, 0x0
invoke-virtual {p0, v0}, Lcom/example/Foo;->bar(I)V
iget-object v1, p0, Lcom/example/Foo;->name:Ljava/lang/String;
add-int v0, v0, v1
return-void
"""

SAMPLE_JAVA_SOURCE = """\
public void doStuff() {
    int x = 0;
    bar(x);
    String n = this.name;
    x = x + n;
}
"""


def _make_encoded_method(
    class_name="Lcom/example/Foo;",
    method_name="doStuff",
    descriptor="()V",
    code=None,
):
    """Create a mock EncodedMethod."""
    enc = MagicMock()
    enc.get_class_name.return_value = class_name
    enc.get_name.return_value = method_name
    enc.get_descriptor.return_value = descriptor
    enc.get_code.return_value = code
    return enc


def _make_xref_entry_4x(class_name, method_name, offset=0):
    """Create a mock xref tuple in androguard 4.x format.

    4.x: (ClassAnalysis, MethodAnalysis, offset)
    MethodAnalysis has .get_method() returning the EncodedMethod.
    """
    ref_class = MagicMock()
    ref_method = MagicMock()
    inner_enc = MagicMock()
    inner_enc.get_class_name.return_value = class_name
    inner_enc.get_name.return_value = method_name
    ref_method.get_method.return_value = inner_enc
    # Remove direct get_class_name/get_name to simulate 4.x behavior
    del ref_method.get_class_name
    del ref_method.get_name
    return (ref_class, ref_method, offset)


def _make_xref_entry_3x(class_name, method_name, offset=0):
    """Create a mock xref tuple in androguard 3.x format.

    3.x: (ClassAnalysis, EncodedMethod, offset)
    EncodedMethod has .get_class_name() and .get_name() directly.
    """
    ref_class = MagicMock()
    ref_method = MagicMock(spec=[
        "get_class_name", "get_name",
    ])
    ref_method.get_class_name.return_value = class_name
    ref_method.get_name.return_value = method_name
    return (ref_class, ref_method, offset)


def _make_method_analysis(
    encoded=None,
    is_external=False,
    xref_from=None,
    xref_to=None,
):
    """Create a mock MethodAnalysis."""
    method = MagicMock()
    method.is_external.return_value = is_external
    method.get_method.return_value = encoded or _make_encoded_method()
    method.get_xref_from.return_value = xref_from or []
    method.get_xref_to.return_value = xref_to or []
    return method


def _make_analyzer(min_instructions=1):
    """Create an APKCodeAnalyzer with mocked dependencies."""
    with patch(
        "redb.extractors.decompiler.apk.analyzer.JADXDecompiler"
    ), patch(
        "redb.extractors.decompiler.apk.analyzer.ApktoolDisassembler"
    ):
        from redb.extractors.decompiler.apk.analyzer import APKCodeAnalyzer
        analyzer = APKCodeAnalyzer("/fake/path.apk")
        analyzer.min_instructions = min_instructions
        analyzer.library_filter = MagicMock()
        analyzer.library_filter.is_library.return_value = False
        return analyzer


def _empty_results():
    """Create a fresh empty results dict."""
    return {
        "decompiled_content": [],
        "decompiled_refs": [],
        "smali_content": [],
        "smali_refs": [],
        "similarity_metrics": [],
        "cfg": [],
        "analysis_errors": [],
    }


def _make_smali_method(body=SAMPLE_SMALI_BODY, instruction_count=5):
    """Create a mock SmaliMethod."""
    m = MagicMock()
    m.body = body
    m.instruction_count = instruction_count
    m.register_count = 2
    return m


# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
# Tests: xref extraction
# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------

class TestXrefExtraction:
    """Tests that xrefs are correctly extracted from androguard objects."""

    def test_xref_from_androguard_4x(self):
        """4.x: ref_method.get_method().get_class_name() path."""
        analyzer = _make_analyzer()
        results = _empty_results()
        method_key = "Lcom/example/Foo;->doStuff()V"

        xref_from = [
            _make_xref_entry_4x("Lcom/example/Caller;", "init", 42),
            _make_xref_entry_4x("Lcom/example/Other;", "run", 100),
        ]
        method = _make_method_analysis(xref_from=xref_from)

        smali_methods = {method_key: _make_smali_method()}
        java_methods = {"com.example.Foo.doStuff": SAMPLE_JAVA_SOURCE}

        analyzer._process_method(
            method, smali_methods, java_methods,
            results, set(), set(),
        )

        assert len(results["decompiled_refs"]) == 1
        ref = results["decompiled_refs"][0]
        assert ref["functions_caller"] == [
            "Lcom/example/Caller;->init",
            "Lcom/example/Other;->run",
        ]

    def test_xref_to_androguard_4x(self):
        """4.x: callees extracted via get_method() unwrap."""
        analyzer = _make_analyzer()
        results = _empty_results()
        method_key = "Lcom/example/Foo;->doStuff()V"

        xref_to = [
            _make_xref_entry_4x("Lcom/example/Dep;", "calculate", 10),
        ]
        method = _make_method_analysis(xref_to=xref_to)

        smali_methods = {method_key: _make_smali_method()}
        java_methods = {"com.example.Foo.doStuff": SAMPLE_JAVA_SOURCE}

        analyzer._process_method(
            method, smali_methods, java_methods,
            results, set(), set(),
        )

        ref = results["decompiled_refs"][0]
        assert ref["functions_call"] == ["Lcom/example/Dep;->calculate"]

    def test_xref_from_androguard_3x_fallback(self):
        """3.x: ref_method.get_class_name() direct access fallback."""
        analyzer = _make_analyzer()
        results = _empty_results()
        method_key = "Lcom/example/Foo;->doStuff()V"

        xref_from = [
            _make_xref_entry_3x("Lcom/example/OldCaller;", "legacy"),
        ]
        method = _make_method_analysis(xref_from=xref_from)

        smali_methods = {method_key: _make_smali_method()}
        java_methods = {"com.example.Foo.doStuff": SAMPLE_JAVA_SOURCE}

        analyzer._process_method(
            method, smali_methods, java_methods,
            results, set(), set(),
        )

        ref = results["decompiled_refs"][0]
        assert ref["functions_caller"] == ["Lcom/example/OldCaller;->legacy"]

    def test_xref_to_androguard_3x_fallback(self):
        """3.x: callees via direct access fallback."""
        analyzer = _make_analyzer()
        results = _empty_results()
        method_key = "Lcom/example/Foo;->doStuff()V"

        xref_to = [
            _make_xref_entry_3x("Lcom/example/OldDep;", "compute"),
        ]
        method = _make_method_analysis(xref_to=xref_to)

        smali_methods = {method_key: _make_smali_method()}
        java_methods = {"com.example.Foo.doStuff": SAMPLE_JAVA_SOURCE}

        analyzer._process_method(
            method, smali_methods, java_methods,
            results, set(), set(),
        )

        ref = results["decompiled_refs"][0]
        assert ref["functions_call"] == ["Lcom/example/OldDep;->compute"]

    def test_empty_xrefs(self):
        """No xrefs produces empty lists, not None."""
        analyzer = _make_analyzer()
        results = _empty_results()
        method_key = "Lcom/example/Foo;->doStuff()V"

        method = _make_method_analysis()
        smali_methods = {method_key: _make_smali_method()}
        java_methods = {"com.example.Foo.doStuff": SAMPLE_JAVA_SOURCE}

        analyzer._process_method(
            method, smali_methods, java_methods,
            results, set(), set(),
        )

        ref = results["decompiled_refs"][0]
        assert ref["functions_caller"] == []
        assert ref["functions_call"] == []

    def test_xref_exception_does_not_crash(self):
        """If get_xref_from() itself throws, method still processes."""
        analyzer = _make_analyzer()
        results = _empty_results()
        method_key = "Lcom/example/Foo;->doStuff()V"

        method = _make_method_analysis()
        method.get_xref_from.side_effect = RuntimeError("xref table corrupt")
        method.get_xref_to.side_effect = RuntimeError("xref table corrupt")

        smali_methods = {method_key: _make_smali_method()}
        java_methods = {"com.example.Foo.doStuff": SAMPLE_JAVA_SOURCE}

        analyzer._process_method(
            method, smali_methods, java_methods,
            results, set(), set(),
        )

        # Method should still be processed with empty xrefs
        assert len(results["smali_refs"]) == 1
        ref = results["decompiled_refs"][0]
        assert ref["functions_caller"] == []
        assert ref["functions_call"] == []

    def test_multiple_xrefs(self):
        """Multiple callers and callees are all captured."""
        analyzer = _make_analyzer()
        results = _empty_results()
        method_key = "Lcom/example/Foo;->doStuff()V"

        xref_from = [
            _make_xref_entry_4x("Lcom/A;", "a1"),
            _make_xref_entry_4x("Lcom/B;", "b1"),
            _make_xref_entry_4x("Lcom/C;", "c1"),
        ]
        xref_to = [
            _make_xref_entry_4x("Lcom/D;", "d1"),
            _make_xref_entry_4x("Lcom/E;", "e1"),
        ]
        method = _make_method_analysis(xref_from=xref_from, xref_to=xref_to)

        smali_methods = {method_key: _make_smali_method()}
        java_methods = {"com.example.Foo.doStuff": SAMPLE_JAVA_SOURCE}

        analyzer._process_method(
            method, smali_methods, java_methods,
            results, set(), set(),
        )

        ref = results["decompiled_refs"][0]
        assert len(ref["functions_caller"]) == 3
        assert len(ref["functions_call"]) == 2


# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
# Tests: method filtering and skipping
# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------

class TestMethodFiltering:
    """Tests for external/library/min-instruction filtering."""

    def test_external_method_skipped(self):
        """External methods (no code body) produce no output."""
        analyzer = _make_analyzer()
        results = _empty_results()

        method = _make_method_analysis(is_external=True)

        analyzer._process_method(
            method, {}, {}, results, set(), set(),
        )

        assert all(len(v) == 0 for v in results.values())

    def test_library_method_skipped(self):
        """Library methods produce no output."""
        analyzer = _make_analyzer()
        analyzer.library_filter.is_library.return_value = True
        results = _empty_results()

        method = _make_method_analysis()

        analyzer._process_method(
            method, {}, {}, results, set(), set(),
        )

        assert all(len(v) == 0 for v in results.values())

    def test_min_instruction_filter(self):
        """Methods below min_instructions threshold are skipped."""
        analyzer = _make_analyzer(min_instructions=10)
        results = _empty_results()
        method_key = "Lcom/example/Foo;->doStuff()V"

        method = _make_method_analysis()
        # Only 3 instructions — below threshold of 10
        smali_methods = {method_key: _make_smali_method(instruction_count=3)}

        analyzer._process_method(
            method, smali_methods, {}, results, set(), set(),
        )

        assert all(len(v) == 0 for v in results.values())

    def test_method_above_min_instructions_processed(self):
        """Methods at or above threshold are processed."""
        analyzer = _make_analyzer(min_instructions=5)
        results = _empty_results()
        method_key = "Lcom/example/Foo;->doStuff()V"

        method = _make_method_analysis()
        smali_methods = {method_key: _make_smali_method(instruction_count=5)}

        analyzer._process_method(
            method, smali_methods, {}, results, set(), set(),
        )

        assert len(results["smali_content"]) == 1
        assert len(results["smali_refs"]) == 1


# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
# Tests: smali body lookup and androguard fallback
# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------

class TestSmaliLookup:
    """Tests for smali body lookup from apktool and androguard fallback."""

    def test_apktool_smali_used_when_available(self):
        """When apktool smali is available, it's used."""
        analyzer = _make_analyzer()
        results = _empty_results()
        method_key = "Lcom/example/Foo;->doStuff()V"

        method = _make_method_analysis()
        smali_methods = {method_key: _make_smali_method()}

        analyzer._process_method(
            method, smali_methods, {}, results, set(), set(),
        )

        assert len(results["smali_content"]) == 1
        assert results["smali_content"][0]["smali_method"] == SAMPLE_SMALI_BODY

    def test_androguard_fallback_when_no_apktool(self):
        """When apktool smali is missing, _disassemble_with_androguard is used."""
        analyzer = _make_analyzer()
        results = _empty_results()

        # Create encoded method with code
        instruction1 = MagicMock()
        instruction1.get_name.return_value = "const/4"
        instruction1.get_output.return_value = "v0, 0x0"
        instruction2 = MagicMock()
        instruction2.get_name.return_value = "invoke-virtual"
        instruction2.get_output.return_value = "v0, Lcom/Foo;->bar()V"
        instruction3 = MagicMock()
        instruction3.get_name.return_value = "add-int"
        instruction3.get_output.return_value = "v0, v1, v2"
        instruction4 = MagicMock()
        instruction4.get_name.return_value = "sub-int"
        instruction4.get_output.return_value = "v3, v0, v1"
        instruction5 = MagicMock()
        instruction5.get_name.return_value = "return-void"
        instruction5.get_output.return_value = ""

        code = MagicMock()
        code.get_registers_size.return_value = 4
        bytecode = MagicMock()
        bytecode.get_instructions.return_value = [
            instruction1, instruction2, instruction3, instruction4, instruction5,
        ]
        code.get_bc.return_value = bytecode

        encoded = _make_encoded_method(code=code)
        method = _make_method_analysis(encoded=encoded)

        # Empty smali_methods — forces androguard fallback
        analyzer._process_method(
            method, {}, {}, results, set(), set(),
        )

        assert len(results["smali_content"]) == 1
        body = results["smali_content"][0]["smali_method"]
        assert "const/4" in body
        assert "return-void" in body

    def test_androguard_fallback_no_code(self):
        """When encoded method has no code, method is skipped."""
        analyzer = _make_analyzer()
        results = _empty_results()

        encoded = _make_encoded_method(code=None)
        method = _make_method_analysis(encoded=encoded)

        analyzer._process_method(
            method, {}, {}, results, set(), set(),
        )

        assert all(len(v) == 0 for v in results.values())

    def test_androguard_fallback_bytecode_exception(self):
        """When bytecode iteration throws, method is skipped gracefully."""
        analyzer = _make_analyzer()
        results = _empty_results()

        code = MagicMock()
        code.get_registers_size.return_value = 2
        bytecode = MagicMock()
        bytecode.get_instructions.side_effect = RuntimeError("bad bytecode")
        code.get_bc.return_value = bytecode

        encoded = _make_encoded_method(code=code)
        method = _make_method_analysis(encoded=encoded)

        analyzer._process_method(
            method, {}, {}, results, set(), set(),
        )

        # Should not crash, but no content produced
        assert len(results["smali_content"]) == 0


# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
# Tests: output population and deduplication
# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------

class TestOutputPopulation:
    """Tests that all result dict keys are correctly populated."""

    def _process_standard_method(self, with_java=True):
        """Helper: process a standard method and return results."""
        analyzer = _make_analyzer()
        results = _empty_results()
        method_key = "Lcom/example/Foo;->doStuff()V"

        xref_from = [_make_xref_entry_4x("Lcom/Caller;", "call")]
        xref_to = [_make_xref_entry_4x("Lcom/Dep;", "dep")]
        method = _make_method_analysis(
            xref_from=xref_from, xref_to=xref_to
        )

        smali_methods = {method_key: _make_smali_method()}
        java_methods = {}
        if with_java:
            java_methods = {"com.example.Foo.doStuff": SAMPLE_JAVA_SOURCE}

        analyzer._process_method(
            method, smali_methods, java_methods,
            results, set(), set(),
        )
        return results

    def test_smali_content_populated(self):
        results = self._process_standard_method()
        assert len(results["smali_content"]) == 1
        entry = results["smali_content"][0]
        assert "smali_method_hash" in entry
        assert entry["smali_method"] == SAMPLE_SMALI_BODY
        assert entry["smali_method_type"] == "USER"
        assert entry["smali_instructions_count"] == 5
        assert isinstance(entry["smali_has_string_encryption"], bool)
        assert isinstance(entry["smali_has_reflection_calls"], bool)
        assert isinstance(entry["smali_excessive_goto_count"], bool)

    def test_smali_refs_populated(self):
        results = self._process_standard_method()
        assert len(results["smali_refs"]) == 1
        ref = results["smali_refs"][0]
        assert "smali_method_hash" in ref
        assert ref["smali_class_name"] == "com.example.Foo"
        assert ref["smali_method_name"] == "doStuff"
        assert ref["smali_method_signature"] == "()V"

    def test_decompiled_content_populated_with_java(self):
        results = self._process_standard_method(with_java=True)
        assert len(results["decompiled_content"]) == 1
        entry = results["decompiled_content"][0]
        assert "decompiled_method_hash" in entry
        assert entry["decompiled_method"] == SAMPLE_JAVA_SOURCE

    def test_decompiled_refs_populated_with_java(self):
        results = self._process_standard_method(with_java=True)
        assert len(results["decompiled_refs"]) == 1
        ref = results["decompiled_refs"][0]
        assert "decompiled_method_hash" in ref
        assert "smali_method_hash" in ref
        assert ref["decompiled_class_name"] == "com.example.Foo"
        assert ref["decompiled_method_name"] == "doStuff"
        assert "decompiled_method_prototype" in ref
        assert ref["functions_caller"] == ["Lcom/Caller;->call"]
        assert ref["functions_call"] == ["Lcom/Dep;->dep"]

    def test_no_decompiled_without_java(self):
        results = self._process_standard_method(with_java=False)
        assert len(results["decompiled_content"]) == 0
        assert len(results["decompiled_refs"]) == 0
        # Smali should still be there
        assert len(results["smali_content"]) == 1

    def test_similarity_metrics_populated(self):
        results = self._process_standard_method()
        assert len(results["similarity_metrics"]) == 1
        sim = results["similarity_metrics"][0]
        assert "smali_method_hash" in sim
        assert "cyclomatic_complexity" in sim
        assert "minhash" in sim
        assert isinstance(sim["minhash"], list)
        # block_count moved to cfg table
        assert "block_count" not in sim

    def test_cfg_entry_populated(self):
        results = self._process_standard_method()
        assert len(results["cfg"]) == 1
        cfg = results["cfg"][0]
        assert "smali_method_hash" in cfg
        assert "block_count" in cfg
        assert "cfg_topology_hash" in cfg
        assert "prime_product_smali" in cfg
        assert "wl_minhash" in cfg
        assert "bb_features" in cfg
        assert isinstance(cfg["bb_features"], list)
        for feat in cfg["bb_features"]:
            assert len(feat) == 8

    def test_smali_deduplication(self):
        """Same smali body processed twice produces one content entry."""
        analyzer = _make_analyzer()
        results = _empty_results()
        method_key = "Lcom/example/Foo;->doStuff()V"
        seen_smali = set()

        method = _make_method_analysis()
        smali_methods = {method_key: _make_smali_method()}

        # Process same method twice
        analyzer._process_method(
            method, smali_methods, {}, results, set(), seen_smali,
        )
        analyzer._process_method(
            method, smali_methods, {}, results, set(), seen_smali,
        )

        # Content deduplicated, but refs are per-call
        assert len(results["smali_content"]) == 1
        assert len(results["smali_refs"]) == 2

    def test_decompiled_deduplication(self):
        """Same Java source processed twice produces one content entry."""
        analyzer = _make_analyzer()
        results = _empty_results()
        method_key = "Lcom/example/Foo;->doStuff()V"
        seen_decompiled = set()
        seen_smali = set()

        method = _make_method_analysis()
        smali_methods = {method_key: _make_smali_method()}
        java_methods = {"com.example.Foo.doStuff": SAMPLE_JAVA_SOURCE}

        analyzer._process_method(
            method, smali_methods, java_methods,
            results, seen_decompiled, seen_smali,
        )
        analyzer._process_method(
            method, smali_methods, java_methods,
            results, seen_decompiled, seen_smali,
        )

        assert len(results["decompiled_content"]) == 1
        assert len(results["decompiled_refs"]) == 2


# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
# Tests: _disassemble_with_androguard
# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------

class TestDisassembleWithAndroguard:
    """Tests for the androguard bytecode disassembly fallback."""

    def test_no_code_returns_none(self):
        from redb.extractors.decompiler.apk.analyzer import APKCodeAnalyzer
        encoded = _make_encoded_method(code=None)
        body, count, regs = APKCodeAnalyzer._disassemble_with_androguard(encoded)
        assert body is None
        assert count == 0
        assert regs == 0

    def test_no_bytecode_returns_none(self):
        from redb.extractors.decompiler.apk.analyzer import APKCodeAnalyzer
        code = MagicMock()
        code.get_registers_size.return_value = 3
        code.get_bc.return_value = None
        encoded = _make_encoded_method(code=code)

        body, count, regs = APKCodeAnalyzer._disassemble_with_androguard(encoded)
        assert body is None
        assert count == 0
        assert regs == 3

    def test_basic_disassembly(self):
        from redb.extractors.decompiler.apk.analyzer import APKCodeAnalyzer

        instructions = []
        for name, output in [
            ("const/4", "v0, 0x0"),
            ("invoke-virtual", "v0, Lcom/Foo;->bar()V"),
            ("return-void", ""),
        ]:
            instr = MagicMock()
            instr.get_name.return_value = name
            instr.get_output.return_value = output
            instructions.append(instr)

        code = MagicMock()
        code.get_registers_size.return_value = 2
        bytecode = MagicMock()
        bytecode.get_instructions.return_value = instructions
        code.get_bc.return_value = bytecode

        encoded = _make_encoded_method(code=code)
        body, count, regs = APKCodeAnalyzer._disassemble_with_androguard(encoded)

        assert body is not None
        assert count == 3
        assert regs == 2
        assert "const/4" in body
        assert "return-void" in body

    def test_invoke_operands_normalized(self):
        """Androguard invoke output gets braces added around registers."""
        from redb.extractors.decompiler.apk.analyzer import APKCodeAnalyzer

        instr = MagicMock()
        instr.get_name.return_value = "invoke-virtual"
        # Androguard format: no braces
        instr.get_output.return_value = "v0, v1, Lcom/Foo;->bar(I)V"

        code = MagicMock()
        code.get_registers_size.return_value = 2
        bytecode = MagicMock()
        bytecode.get_instructions.return_value = [instr]
        code.get_bc.return_value = bytecode

        encoded = _make_encoded_method(code=code)
        body, count, regs = APKCodeAnalyzer._disassemble_with_androguard(encoded)

        # Should be normalized to apktool format with braces
        assert "{v0, v1}" in body

    def test_bytecode_exception_returns_none(self):
        from redb.extractors.decompiler.apk.analyzer import APKCodeAnalyzer

        code = MagicMock()
        code.get_registers_size.return_value = 2
        bytecode = MagicMock()
        bytecode.get_instructions.side_effect = RuntimeError("corrupt")
        code.get_bc.return_value = bytecode

        encoded = _make_encoded_method(code=code)
        body, count, regs = APKCodeAnalyzer._disassemble_with_androguard(encoded)

        assert body is None
        assert regs == 2